Managing a Reactive Dog: What Every Owner Needs to Know

Introduction

Reactivity in dogs is often misunderstood as bad behavior, but in reality, it’s a response to stress, fear, or excitement. Many reactive dogs struggle because they are frequently pushed past their threshold, the point where they go from calm to reacting

.

In this blog, we’ll explore:

✅ What a threshold is

✅ Why it’s important in training

✅ How to recognize and work within your dog’s threshold to help them feel safe and confident

By understanding and respecting your dog’s threshold, you can make reactivity training more effective and reduce stress for both of you.

What is a Threshold?

The threshold is the point at which your dog shifts from being calm and in control to feeling stressed and reactive. Think of it as their breaking point, once they have crossed it, they struggle to focus, learn, or respond to training cues.

Understanding Threshold Levels

Below Threshold: Your dog notices a trigger (like another dog, a loud noise, or a stranger) but remains calm. They can take treats, follow cues, and stay engaged with you.

Approaching Threshold: Your dog starts to show signs of stress, such as staring, stiffening, whining, or increased breathing. They are on the verge of reacting.

Over Threshold: Your dog is fully reactive—barking, lunging, growling, or even shutting down. At this point, they are too stressed to listen or learn.

Example

Imagine your dog is reactive to other dogs. If they see another dog 50 feet away and remain calm, they are below threshold. But at 20 feet, they start whining and staring—that’s approaching threshold. If they get to 10 feet and begin barking and lunging, they are over threshold.

Every dog has a different threshold, and it can vary depending on the situation, the other dog, their mood, or even their energy level that day.

Why Do Thresholds Matter in Training?

Understanding and respecting your dog’s threshold is crucial for effective reactivity training. When a dog is over threshold, their brain shifts into fight-or-flight mode, making it impossible for them to focus or learn.

Why Training Below Threshold Works

✅ Better Focus: A calm dog can process information, take treats, and respond to training cues.

✅ Less Stress: Keeping your dog under threshold helps prevents negative associations with triggers.

✅ Faster Progress: Training in a safe emotional state helps your dog build confidence over time.

What Happens When a Dog Goes Over Threshold?

❌ They Stop Listening: Reactivity takes over, and they can’t follow cues.

❌ They Build Negative Associations: Repeated stress reinforces fear and makes reactivity worse.

❌ It Can Take Hours to Recover: Once overstimulated, a dog may stay stressed long after the trigger is gone.

By recognizing and working below threshold, you set your dog up for success instead of frustration.

How to Use Thresholds in Reactivity Training

Now that you understand what a threshold is and why it matters, let’s talk about how to use it to help your dog.

The goal is to train at a level where your dog notices a trigger but stays calm and below threshold so they can learn without stress.

Step 1: Identify Your Dog’s Threshold

Observe your dog’s reactions to their trigger (e.g., other dogs, strangers, loud noises). Pay attention to the distance or intensity where they begin to show stress signals like staring, stiffening, or whining.

Example: If your dog starts reacting when another dog is 20 feet away, their threshold is likely around that distance.

Step 2: Work Below Threshold

Start training at a distance where your dog notices the trigger but remains calm. Reward them with treats or praise for staying relaxed.

Example: If your dog reacts at 20 feet, begin training at 30-40 feet, where they can see the other dog but don’t get overwhelmed.

Step 3: Gradually Decrease Distance

As your dog becomes comfortable, slowly reduce the distance while reinforcing calm behavior. Go at their pace, rushing can push them over threshold and undo progress.

Example: After several successful sessions at 30 feet, try moving to 25 feet. If they stay calm, continue decreasing in small increments over time.

Step 4: Use High-Value Rewards

When your dog stays below threshold, reward them with their favorite treats, toys, or praise. This creates positive associations with the trigger and encourages calm behavior.

Tip: If your dog refuses treats, they may already be too close to their threshold—move further away and try again.

Step 5: Be Patient and Consistent

Building confidence takes time! Some days your dog may tolerate being closer, while other days they need more space. Respect their comfort level and celebrate small wins.

Conclusion

Understanding and respecting your dog’s threshold is one of the most important aspects of reactivity training. By recognizing when they are calm versus overwhelmed, you can create training sessions that are effective, stress-free, and confidence-boosting.

Key Takeaways:

✔ A threshold is the point where a dog goes from calm to reactive.

✔ Training below threshold helps your dog stay focused and learn.

✔ Gradually decreasing distance to triggers builds confidence.

✔ Patience and consistency are key—progress happens at your dog’s pace.

By working with your dog’s emotions rather than against them, you set them up for long-term success. Reactivity isn’t about "fixing" bad behavior—it’s about helping your dog feel safe and comfortable in their world.